When I spotted some adorable felt nativity stickers a while back at Hobby Lobby, I knew exactly what I was going to do with them. They needed to be turned into nativity finger puppets. Since they already had a very strong adhesive on the back of them, I just hot glued two pieces of felt together (leaving room for a finger to fit inside), stuck on the sticker, and then cut around them.
They seriously only took about 10 minutes to make and they seem to be pretty durable. They are a nice toddler-friendly way to retell the birth of our Savior.